Silence isn’t peace

There are two conversations about men happening online right now.

In the first, the volume is rightly turned up on men’s behaviour. After the Russell Brand verdict earlier this month, there’s been a flood of posts saying what women have said for years: men need to take responsibility and hold their mates to a higher standard. I agree with every word.

In the second, men’s pain is raised. Men die by suicide in far greater numbers. Men do most of the dangerous work. We’re raised to be strong, not to cry. I agree with that too.

The trouble is that these two conversations often treat each other as enemies. One says “not all men” and gets met with “always a man”. The other says “men are victims too” and gets heard as deflection.

On my lunchtime run today, I realised they’re the same conversation. And, in typical manly fashion, we're avoiding it.

Accountability comes first
Let me be clear about where I stand. Harm is harm. Pain explains nothing away. Whatever a man has been through, he is accountable for what he does. In my tradition, that applies to each of us, regardless of our gender, and in the sight of our Creator we are equal except by the weight of our deeds.

When a man harms a woman, there is only one correct response - accountability. And the first people saying “not on our watch” should be other men.

Interestingly, this month holds two reminders a week apart: International Men’s Day on 19 November and White Ribbon Day on 25 November. We tend to treat them as opposing causes. They aren’t.

The pain is real too
In New Zealand, the suspected suicide rate for men is nearly three times that of women (Te Whatu Ora). In Australia, about three in four people who die by suicide are men (ABS). And in Australia in 2024, 96 per cent of workers killed on the job were men (WHS).

I’m not offering these as a counterweight. I’m offering them as a fact about what happens when a generation of men is taught that the right response to pain is to carry it quietly. 

Where the two meet
When boys learn that feelings are weakness, and the men around them model contempt, control or explosions, many learn to bury what they feel. Buried things don’t disappear. Some men turn the pain inward, towards depression, withdrawal and sometimes worse. Some turn it outward.

I’m not claiming a straight line. Most men in pain never harm anyone else, though their silence still costs the people who love them. And not every man who harms someone is a man in pain. But the same root, men who haven’t learned to say what’s going on inside, shows up on both sides of the ledger.

I don’t believe anyone is born evil. In my tradition, every child is born upon a natural disposition towards goodness, and a Prophetic tradition tells us it’s the people around the child - and, by extension, the world around him - who shape which way he turns. That isn’t an excuse. It’s a responsibility, for how we raise our sons and for what we model in front of them.

My own silence
I’ll be honest about my part.

I am loyal, and I don’t give up easily. Both are strengths, and both have a shadow. Professionally, I am good at separating the issue from the person, and it’s part of what I help others do. But with people and things close to my heart, I flinch. I stay quiet. I keep the peace. And keeping the peace, I’ve learned, isn’t the same as having it. The resentment goes somewhere, and it’s affected some of my relationships.

These days I try to do two things. First, I notice what I’m doing and name it to myself. Then I weigh what avoiding will cost against what fronting up will cost. Brené Brown’s line helps: Clear is kind, unclear is unkind.

Silence, I’ve often told myself, feels like kindness. But hindsight’s taught me that it’s often the unkind option.

What men can actually do
I see very little point in all the reflection when there's no action - something that can actually make a difference in our lives. So, here are my suggestions for what's helped me:

1 - Ask twice.

  • “How are you?” Then, “No, how are you really?”

  • Look him in the eye when you ask this.

2 - Look for signs.

  • Notice changes from how he usually is - in sleep, appetite, mood, energy, drinking, smoking or withdrawal.

  • In workplaces, increased or patterned absence or uncharacteristically poor performance or behaviour might be a call for help.

  • A change is a reason to ask, not a diagnosis or conclusion.

3 - Name it.

  • When a mate crosses a line, call it out. With care, but say it.

  • Don't laugh along to supposed jokes which demean women or anyone else.

4 - Reach out early.

  • To a friend, a GP, a counsellor, an elder.

  • Don’t wait until it’s heavy.

5 - Normalise expression.

  • In any circle you're in, and especially if you have a leadership capacity, make it safe to say “I’m not okay” and to say “that wasn’t okay”.

6 - Ask directly.

  • If you’re worried someone might be thinking about suicide, ask them directly.

  • Asking won’t put the idea in their head. 

Final thought
I still have questions I’m sitting with - and I’d invite you to sit with them too:

  • Where are you keeping the peace when it's really just silent conflict?

  • Is there a mate you need to ask twice, or someone whose behaviour you need to name?

  • What did you learn about being a man when you were a boy - and which of those lessons are you still passing on?

  • If you lead: what do the people around you learn from how you handle feelings and conflict?

Because silence isn’t peace. It’s a deferred cost which someone inevitably has to pay.

Support
If this has stirred something for you: in Aotearoa New Zealand, free call or text 1737 any time. In Australia, Lifeline is 13 11 14. In South Africa, SADAG’s Suicide Crisis Helpline is 0800 567 567. In an emergency, call 111 (NZ) or 000 (Australia). In South Africa, call 112 from a mobile, 10111 for police or 10177 for an ambulance. Elsewhere, findahelpline.com lists services by country.

If you’re affected by gender-based violence: in Aotearoa, Women’s Refuge is 0800 733 843 (0800 REFUGE), free any time. In Australia, call 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732. In South Africa, the Gender-Based Violence Command Centre is 0800 428 428, free and open 24 hours, or dial 1207867# from any cellphone to ask for a call back.

And if you’re worried about your own behaviour and want to change it: in Aotearoa, Hey Bro is 0800 439 276 (0800 HEY BRO). In Australia, the Men’s Referral Service is 1300 766 491.

Go on. Take the Next Step.

Next
Next

#Theweekthatwas @ 15/11/2026